This doesn’t seem like a good idea.

From the Inky (link here):

Philadelphia soft-drink tax proposed
Philadelphia could soon jump to the head of the public health class with new initiatives aimed at pushing residents toward healthier diets.

Earlier this year the city began to enforce new requirements that city restaurants display food labels on menus with information on calories and other information such as fat content. And now – at least under Mayor Nutter’s proposed soft drink tax – the price of unhealthy sugar-sweetened drinks will go up.

That might reduce consumption in a similar manner as cigarette taxes attempt to reduce smoking, particularly among teens. Regardless, the tax would add an estimated $77 million to the city’s coffers.

The mayor’s proposed 2010-2011 city budget includes a 2 cents an ounce tax on all sugar-sweetened drinks from sodas to energy drinks and more. The proposed tax would not be imposed on baby formula and sugar free drinks. But it would mean an extra 40 cents for a 20-once bottle of Coke and 64 cents added to each quart of chocolate milk.

City health commissioner Donald L. Schwarz said $20 million of the estimated tax haul would go toward programs to promote exercise and healthy eating habits, my colleague Jeff Shields reported in today’s paper.

Shields noted that New York, Massachusetts, and California are among seven states considering similar taxes on sugar-sweetened drinks. But Nutter’s proposed tax is double New York’s and far more than Chicago’s 3 percent a drink tax. Chicago, Shields noted, is the only other major city with such a soft-drink tax.

Just last month, the city began phasing in enforcement of its strictest-in-the-nation menu-labeling law that requires restaurant chains to list calories on food tags and menu boards. A similar law will take effect in New Jersey next year, and dozens of such bills are pending around the country, including in Harrisburg.

On April 1, Philadelphia restaurants with individual menus must list calories as well as saturated fats, trans fats, carbohydrates, and sodium for each item offered. Earlier this year, my colleague Don Sapatkin reported that City Council approved the restaurant menu measure in 2008 in response to data that showed the impact of diet related chronic illnesses such as diabetes and high blood pressure.

The goal of the law was to make it simpler for people to make healthy eating choices, even when they are enjoying a night out at a restaurant. “It is really hard for people, if they eat out, to know about the sodium content” of a meal, for example, health commissioner Schwarz told Sapatkin in January.

So whether requiring restaurants to tell people how healthy each item on the menu is or a proposed tax on obesity inducing soft drinks, Philadelphia seems to on the leading edge of the push toward better nutrition and perhaps better public health.

Good fucking Christ. You don’t even know how friggin happy I am that I don’t live in the city anymore. Please, Philadelphia city government, keep giving residents less and less reasons to stick around that shithole city. Maybe the next thing you can do is make it illegal to be a Democrat.

Hey, Mayor Nutter, I just figured you were doing everything in your power to drive out the remaining population of the city. You’re certainly attacking the poor a whole hell of a lot, even though there are significant chunks of both poverty stricken and working/lower-middle class populations. (And who tends to wash down a delicious cigarette with some cloyingly sweet HFCSy goodness? Oh, rite, the poor.)

I’m tired and aggravated and so thankful that I’m Delaware County and, therefore, much closer to taxfree shopping. I kept meaning to post about this somewhere, and hoped to give it a little bit more critical treatment, but damnit, I really can’t sleep right now.

So, sorry, but right now? Ya get whatcha get.

Advertisements

3 Responses so far »

  1. 1

    Joe said,

    I like how this is portrayed as some kind of progressive health policy, when it’s transparently a case of the city being strapped for cash and looking for new ways to fleece its dwindling population. What a joke.

    Even funnier is this: “City health commissioner Donald L. Schwarz said $20 million of the estimated tax haul would go toward programs to promote exercise and healthy eating habits, my colleague Jeff Shields reported in today’s paper.”

    • 2

      Joe, how dare you imply that it’s not to save the children! You act like Philly’s broke and 5 years away from becoming Port-au-Prince (post-hurricane, of course). Geeze, don’t you know that high taxes are progress??!?!?!?!??!?!!

  2. 3

    Marc said,

    Add to that a 6% fare hike for septa next year…

    They just can’t rob poor people enough.


Comment RSS · TrackBack URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: